Choose the Right Respirator and Filters for Welding

Welding produces hazardous fumes and gases that can pose significant health risks if not properly managed. Protecting welders from exposure is essential to maintaining workplace safety and ensuring compliance with occupational safety regulations.

Effective fume extraction is the primary control measure for reducing exposure. Equipment such as MIG guns with integrated extraction, flexible arms, and extraction nozzles are designed to capture fumes at their source. Proper ventilation systems are crucial to keeping exposure within permissible exposure limits (PELs), as defined by safety standards.

In situations where ventilation alone cannot achieve acceptable limits, respirators serve as a vital secondary or temporary solution. They provide additional protection, ensuring welders can continue working safely until optimal ventilation is established.

Regulatory Context

Permissible Exposure Limits (PELs)

Welding safety is governed by strict regulations designed to protect workers from hazardous fume exposure. PELs are critical benchmarks that define acceptable levels of airborne contaminants within the welder’s breathing zone. They are the primary factor in selecting respiratory protection and emphasize the importance of source extraction as the first step toward compliance. Key resources for PELs include:

• US Welding Fume Regulations
• Canadian Welding Fume Regulations

Any questions? Ask them directly in the chat at the bottom right of your screen or during one of our webinars.

Respirators Regulations

Respirator usage and standards differ across countries, with specific guidelines designed to ensure safety and compliance.

• United States: OSHA’s Respiratory Protection Standard (29 CFR 1910.134) outlines detailed requirements for proper respirator use, maintenance, and fit testing. These regulations are essential for implementing an effective respiratory protection program.
• Canada: Each province and territory establishes its own regulations. For instance, in Quebec, respirators must be NIOSH-certified, and respiratory protection programs must conform to CSA Z94.4-11 standards.

Concepts for Respiratory Selection

Choosing the right respirator involves understanding two key concepts:

• Assigned Protection Factor (APF): Represents the level of protection provided by a respirator when used as part of a regulated program. For example, a respirator with an APF of 10 reduces exposure to 1/10th of the contaminant concentration in the air.
• Maximum Use Concentration (MUC): The maximum atmospheric concentration of a substance a respirator can effectively protect against. MUC is calculated using the formula: MUC = APF × PEL (or applicable limit)

Selecting the Right Respiratory Protection

Choosing the appropriate respirator requires careful evaluation of workplace conditions and the hazards present. Key factors to consider include:

• Concentration Levels: Ensure the actual airborne contaminant concentration is below the Maximum Use Concentration (MUC) for the selected respirator.
• Fit: A tight seal is critical for effectiveness. Proper fit testing is essential.
• Comfort: Respirators should not cause discomfort, which could lead to improper usage.
• Cost: Balance initial and long-term costs, including maintenance and replacement filters.
• Filter Life: Monitor and replace filters according to manufacturer guidelines.
• Specific Features: Consider additional needs, such as vapor management or compatibility with welding helmets.

Types of Respirators

Disposable Masks or Half-Mask Respirators

Disposable masks and half-mask respirators typically offer an APF of 10, meaning they provide protection by reducing exposure to 1/10th of the contaminant concentration in the air.

These respirators come with various filter options:

• N95 and N100 filters are not resistant to oil-based aerosols.
• P95 and P100 filters are resistant to both oil and non-oil aerosols.

Efficiency at capturing particles varies by filter:

• N95 and P95 filters provide 95% efficiency at 0.3 microns.
• N100 and P100 filters offer 99.97% efficiency at 0.3 microns.

For environments with highly toxic substances such as chromium-6, beryllium, cadmium, lead, or manganese, P100 filters are ideal. However, N95 is the minimum acceptable standard for general welding fume protection.

A tight seal is essential for respirators to be effective. Fit testing is required to ensure proper sealing, and the respirator must fit comfortably under a welding helmet.

Masks and filters should be replaced when breathing resistance noticeably increases. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines regarding filter shelf life before and after the package is opened.

Disposable Masks

• Pros: No maintenance, low cost, lightweight, fits under helmets.
• Cons: Ineffective with facial hair, can restrict breathability, requires regular fit testing.

Half-Mask Respirators

• Pros: Replaceable filters for extended use, moderate cost, lightweight, offers filter variety.
• Cons: Ineffective with facial hair, may not fit well under helmets, requires fit testing, can affect breathability.

Powered Air-Purifying Respirators (PAPRs)

Powered Air-Purifying Respirators (PAPRs) use a battery-powered blower to draw air through filters or cartridges. The filtered air is delivered via a breathing tube to the welding helmet. The blower unit is typically belt-mounted, making it suitable for extended use in welding environments.

• APF: 25 (higher protection than disposable or half-mask respirators).
• HEPA Filters: Provide 99.97% efficiency at 0.3 microns, ensuring optimal filtration.
• Additional Features: Spark screens and pre-filters prolong HEPA filter life by capturing larger particles.
• Pros: Excellent breathability and cooling, no fit testing required, and compatible with facial hair.
• Cons: High cost, heavier equipment, and more maintenance requirements.

Maintenance

Filters should be replaced whenever the indicator or alarm signals a need for a change. As a general guideline, pre-filters should be replaced every 1 to 3 days, depending on usage and environmental conditions. HEPA filters typically require replacement every 2 to 4 weeks. Always adhere to the manufacturer’s recommendations regarding the shelf life of filters, both before and after the package is opened.

Auto-Darkening Lenses

Auto-darkening lenses automatically adjust their shade to match the intensity of the light produced during welding. Their quality is measured by EN 379 standards, which evaluate optical clarity. The best lenses are rated 1/1/1/1, offering superior clarity and minimal distortion, while lower-rated lenses, such as 3/3/3/3, provide less precision and clarity.

Shade Numbers

Shade numbers determine the level of light filtration provided by the lens. Higher shade numbers correspond to darker filters that reduce light transmission, making them suitable for more intense welding activities.

As a guideline, OSHA recommends using shades ranging from 2 to 14, depending on the welding process.

Welding operation	Shade No.
Shielded metal-arc welding – 1/16 to 5/32-inch electrodes	10
Gas-shielded arc welding (nonferrous) – 1/16 to 5/32-inch electrodes	11
Gas-shielded arc welding (ferrous) – 1/16 to 5/32-inch electrodes	12
Shielded metal-arc welding – 3/16 to 1/4-inch electrodes	12
Shielded metal-arc welding – 5/16 to 3/8-inch electrodes	14
Atomic hydrogen welding	10-14
Carbon arc welding	14
Soldering	2
Torch brazing	3 or 4
Light cutting – up to 1 inch	3 or 4
Medium cutting – 1 to 6 inches	4 or 5
Heavy cutting – 6 inches and over	5 or 6
Gas welding (light) – up to 1/8 inch	4 or 5
Gas welding (medium) – 1/8 to 1/2 inch	5 or 6
Gas welding (heavy) – 1/2 inch and over	6 or 8

 Dust Collectors and Portable Units

Dust collectors and portable units play a significant role in managing airborne particles in welding environments. Their effectiveness is largely determined by the MERV rating (Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value), which measures a filter’s ability to capture particles of various sizes. Ideally, dust collectors should have a MERV rating of 16-17, though a minimum rating of 13 is acceptable.

The table below outlines the efficiency of MERV-rated filters across particle sizes:

MERV Rating	0.3 to 1 Micron	1 to 3 Microns	3 to 10 Microns
13	≥50%	≥85%	≥90%
14	≥75%	≥90%	≥95%
15	≥85%	≥90%	≥95%
16	≥95%	≥95%	≥95%
17-20 (HEPA)	≥99.97%	≥99.97%	≥99.97%

The filter material commonly used in dust collectors is made of cellulose polyester, often with flame-retardant properties for added safety. To ensure optimal performance, the surface area of the filter must align with the airflow requirements (measured in cubic feet per minute or CFM). A recommended air-to-cloth ratio is 1:1 or better, which helps maintain efficiency and extends filter life.

Filters should be replaced based on specific indicators such as filter change alerts, a pressure differential exceeding 8 inches of water, or a visible decline in fume extraction performance.

Maintenance and Best Practices

Regular maintenance is crucial for ensuring the effectiveness of dust collectors and respirators. Filters should be monitored and replaced as indicated by performance metrics. It is also important to ensure that respirators are in good condition, including their filters, masks, and hoses. Fit testing protocols must be followed to guarantee a tight seal, and powered air-purifying respirators (PAPRs) require specific care, such as regular battery checks and filter cleaning.

Conclusion

Proper respiratory protection and filter selection are essential for ensuring a safe and compliant welding environment. By adhering to recommended practices and regulatory standards, welders can minimize health risks and maintain optimal workplace safety. Prioritizing these measures highlights a commitment to worker safety and workplace efficiency.