What is a Welding Fume Extractor? Crash Course

Welding, a critical process in numerous industries, produces fumes that can be hazardous to health if not properly managed. Ensuring the safety and health of welders and those in the immediate environment is paramount.

This is where welding fume extractors come into play. In this blog post, we will delve into what welding fume extractors are, the various types available, and the technologies they employ to maintain a safe and healthy workspace.

Definition of Welding Fume Extractor

A welding fume extractor is designed to remove fumes generated during welding processes. These fumes, if inhaled, can pose serious health risks. The extractor captures welding fumes at the source and filters them out before they can disperse into the work area or outside.

They help comply with occupational health and safety regulations and contribute to a cleaner, more productive working environment. The effectiveness of a welding fume extractor depends on several factors, including its design, the type of filtering technology it uses, and how well it matches the specific welding processes being undertaken.

Main Components of a Welding Fume Extraction System

1. Vacuum Unit: The system’s heart generates suction to capture welding fumes.
2. Dust Collector: This component filters and collects the extracted particulates and fumes. In stationary systems, it is a separate unit; in portable systems, it’s integrated with the vacuum unit.
3. Ventilation Network includes ducts and hoses that transport fumes from the extraction point to the dust collector. The network is typically a simple hose in portable units, whereas stationary systems use a more complex arrangement of ducts and hoses.
4. Extraction Tools: These tools capture welding fumes at the source and can include flexible arms, MIG extraction guns, nozzles, hoods, etc.

Different Types of Captors

Welding fume extractors come in various forms, each tailored to specific needs and welding environments.

Fume Extraction MIG Gun

Fume extraction MIG guns are a premier choice for controlling fumes in MIG welding. These guns extract fumes right after the gas nozzle, channeling them through the handle and a flexible hose integrated with the power cable. The vacuum needed for extraction can be provided by either a portable unit or a central system.

Functionally, they resemble conventional MIG guns, allowing welders to operate as usual. This on-tool extraction method is versatile, practical for various weld lengths and positions, and does not require additional positioning efforts.

Fume Extraction Arm

Fume extraction arms offer a flexible solution for a range of welding processes. They can be mounted on walls, ceilings, or directly on tables. Efficient even when positioned a foot or two away from the welding pool, some arms can cover areas as large as 600 square feet, depending on their length.

Alternatively, portable units with a built-in blower and filter are also available. Proper positioning is crucial for these arms to achieve optimal efficiency.

Fume Extraction Nozzle

When a fume extraction MIG gun is not suitable and the flexibility of an extraction arm is insufficient, fume extraction nozzles provide a viable alternative. These nozzles, often equipped with magnets or suction cups for easy attachment, should be placed close to the welding pool for maximum effectiveness.

While this solution is cost-effective, it requires frequent repositioning by the welder, which can be a drawback in terms of convenience.

Fume Extraction Hood

Fume extraction hoods are generally ineffective for directly protecting welders, as the welder’s head tends to be between the welding area and the hood. However, they excel in scenarios involving robotic welding. In such applications, fume extraction hoods offer unparalleled efficiency, capturing fumes effectively without human intervention.

Downdraft Table

Contrary to some beliefs, downdraft tables are unsuitable for welding fume extraction. The natural upward trajectory of welding fumes at high speeds makes bottom-up extraction ineffective. The airflow required to make downdraft tables efficient for this purpose is often prohibitively expensive. Therefore, while downdraft tables are excellent for plasma cutting or as grinding workstations, they are not recommended for welding fume extraction.

Any questions? Ask them directly in the chat at the bottom right of your screen or during one of our webinars.

Different Types of Technologies in Welding Fume Extraction

The technology employed in welding fume extraction systems varies, each offering distinct advantages depending on the welding environment. Understanding these technologies is crucial for choosing the right approach that balances effectiveness, efficiency, and cost.

Low-Vacuum/High-Volume Systems

These systems are designed to capture and remove a large air volume at a lower vacuum pressure. The primary advantage of low-vacuum/high-volume systems is their versatility and ability to cover larger areas.

They are typically used with fume extraction arms or hoods. However, their efficiency can be limited if the fumes are very concentrated or if precise extraction is required.

High-Vacuum/Low-Volume Systems

In contrast, high-vacuum/low-volume systems focus on extracting fumes at a higher vacuum pressure but deal with a smaller air volume. These systems are more effective for localized fume extraction, such as those used with fume extraction MIG guns or nozzles.

They are particularly suitable for operations where fume production is concentrated in small areas. The high-vacuum force ensures that fumes are captured directly at the source, reducing the overall volume of air that needs to be processed.

We have a resource to help you choose between Low-Vacuum/High-Volume and High-Vacuum/Low-Volume systems.

Mobile vs Stationary Fume Extraction Units

Mobile Units: Mobile fume extractors offer flexibility and are ideal for environments where welding activities are not confined to static locations. These units can be moved around the workshop, allowing for targeted extraction in various workstations. Mobile units are generally smaller and less powerful than stationary ones but are perfect for shops with limited space or those requiring occasional fume extraction in different areas.

Stationary Units: Stationary fume extractors are larger, more powerful systems. These units often have larger capacities and more efficient filtration systems, making them suitable for continuous, heavy-duty use. While they lack the versatility of portable units, their robustness and efficiency make them a preferred choice for most factories.

Once again, you can check our article comparing mobile and stationary units in depth.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Welding Fume Extractor

Welding Process

When selecting the right welding fume extractor, it’s essential to consider various factors, including the welding process, the type of technology suitable for that process, and the environment in which the welding occurs. The table provides a comprehensive guide on which fume extractor type and technology are best suited for different welding processes.

Process	MIG gun	Arm	Nozzle	Hood	Table
Technology	HVLV	LVHV	HVLV	LVHV	LVHV
Mobile vs Stationary	Both	Both	Mobile	Stationary	Stationary
MIG / GMAW	Best	Yes	Yes	No	No
TIG / GTAW	No	Best	Yes	No	No
Fluxed-Cored / FCAW	Best	Yes	Yes	No	No
Stick / SMAW	No	Best	Yes	No	No
Robotic Welding	Yes	Yes	No	Best	No
Aluminum Welding	Best	Yes	Yes	No	No

Other Considerations

• Space and Layout of the Welding Area: Mobile units offer flexibility in smaller or variable spaces, while stationary units are better for dedicated, larger spaces.
• Intensity and Frequency of Welding: High-frequency or high-intensity welding environments may require more robust systems.
• Compliance with Safety Regulations: Ensure the chosen fume extractor meets local safety and health regulations.
• Budget and Operational Costs: Balance the initial investment with long-term operating costs, including maintenance and replacement of filters.

Health and Safety Regulations

When implementing welding fume extractors, it is crucial to understand and comply with health and safety regulations. These regulations often include permissible exposure limits to certain substances, such as manganese, nickel, chromium, and ozone. They are designed to protect workers from the health risks associated with welding fumes and to ensure a safe working environment.

Learn more about regulations and exposure limits in the US and Canada.

Regular Maintenance and Inspection

Regular maintenance and inspection of fume extraction equipment are required to ensure they function correctly and efficiently. This not only helps maintain compliance with regulations but also provides the longevity and effectiveness of the equipment.

Training and Awareness

Providing proper training and raising awareness among the workforce about the risks associated with welding fumes and the importance of using fume extractors correctly is vital. This helps in creating a safety-conscious work culture.

Conclusion

In conclusion, selecting a welding fume extractor requires careful consideration of the welding process, the types of fumes generated, and the specific needs of the welding environment.

One can ensure a safe, efficient, and compliant welding operation by understanding the different types of fume extractors and technologies available and complying with health and safety regulations.