The Impacts of Metal Coatings on Welding Fumes

In the intricate world of welding, understanding the impact of metal coatings on welding fumes is crucial for occupational safety. Metal coatings, while enhancing the functionality and longevity of metal products, can significantly alter the composition of welding fumes.

This article delves into ten common types of metal coatings, exploring their characteristics and the dangers they pose in fumes, thus shedding light on an often-overlooked aspect of welding safety.

Galvanizing (Zinc Coating)

Process Description: Galvanizing involves coating steel or iron with a layer of zinc. This is typically achieved by dipping the metal into a bath of molten zinc, a process known as hot-dip galvanizing. The zinc layer forms a physical barrier and also offers cathodic protection, meaning it will corrode preferentially to the underlying metal, thus protecting it.

Advantages/Reason for Use: The primary advantage of galvanizing is its exceptional corrosion resistance, significantly extending the life of metal structures and components. It’s particularly beneficial for outdoor or marine environments where exposure to moisture and salt can lead to rapid deterioration. Additionally, galvanizing is relatively economical compared to other protective coatings and requires minimal maintenance over its lifespan.

Impact on Welding Fumes: When welding galvanized materials, the high temperatures cause the zinc coating to vaporize before the base metal does, producing zinc oxide fumes. If inhaled, these fumes can lead to metal fume fever, a temporary but unpleasant condition characterized by flu-like symptoms such as chills, fever, and muscle aches.

Learn more about galvanized steel welding fumes here.

Paint Coating

Process Description: Paint coating involves applying a layer of paint to a metal surface. This can be done through various methods, such as brushing, spraying, or dipping. The paint typically consists of pigments (color), binders (hold pigments together), solvents (for consistency), and additives for specific properties like UV resistance, drying time, or flexibility.

Advantages/Reason for Use: Paint coatings are primarily used for their aesthetic appeal, offering various colors and finishes. Beyond aesthetics, these coatings provide a barrier against corrosion, moisture, and chemical exposure. They can also be formulated for specific needs like heat resistance, electrical insulation, or enhanced durability.

Impact on Welding Fumes: Welding on painted surfaces can release various hazardous compounds, depending on the paint’s composition. Older paints may contain lead, posing a risk of lead poisoning. Other paints might release toxic fumes from burning pigments, binders, solvents, or additives. Volatile Organic Compounds, or VOCs, are a significant issue. These fumes can irritate the respiratory system and eyes, and prolonged exposure may lead to more severe health issues (damage to the liver, kidneys, or central nervous system).

Powder Coating

Process Description: Powder coating is a dry finishing process where a powder material (typically a mixture of finely ground particles of pigment and resin) is electrostatically applied to a metal surface and cured under heat to form a hard, protective finish. This method provides a uniform, durable, high-quality finish.

Advantages/Reason for Use: Powder coating offers the same advantages as paint coating but is favored for its durability, cost-effectiveness, and environmental friendliness, as it typically contains no solvents and emits negligible volatile organic compounds (VOCs). It usually provides a more consistent finish than conventional liquid paints and is available in a wide range of colors and textures.

Impact on Welding Fumes: While powder coating is safer in terms of VOCs during application, during welding, the high temperatures can cause the coating to decompose, potentially releasing various compounds. The specific nature of these compounds varies based on the composition of the powder coating but can include organic substances from the resin. These fumes can be irritating to the respiratory system and eyes.

Anodizing (Aluminum)

Process Description: Anodizing is an electrochemical process that converts the metal surface into a decorative, corrosion-resistant, durable, anodic oxide finish. Aluminum is the most commonly anodized material. This process increases the thickness of the natural oxide layer on the surface of metal parts while immersed in an acid electrolyte bath and acting as an anode.

Advantages/Reason for Use: Anodizing enhances corrosion and wear resistance and allows for better paint primer and glue adhesion. It’s also used for cosmetic reasons since the metal can take on various colors.

Impact on Welding Fumes: When welding aluminum, the primary concern is the release of aluminum oxide particles, which is an issue whether or not anodizing is involved. Additionally, if the anodizing contains colored dyes or other additives, these may decompose under the intense welding heat, potentially releasing harmful fumes.

Chromate Coating

Process Description: Chromate coatings are applied to metals (usually aluminum, zinc, steel, and magnesium) to improve corrosion resistance (passivation), enhance paint adhesion, and provide a decorative finish. This process involves the application of a chromate conversion coating, which forms a gel-like layer on the surface.

Advantages/Reason for Use: This type of coating is valued for its ability to provide good corrosion resistance, maintain electrical conductivity, and serve as a primer for subsequent paint or coating layers. It’s widely used in aerospace, automotive, and electronics industries.

Impact on Welding Fumes: The primary concern when welding chromate-coated metals is the potential release of chromium compounds, including hexavalent chromium, a highly toxic and carcinogenic substance. The heat from welding can convert trivalent chromium in the coating to hexavalent chromium in the fumes.

Any questions? Ask them directly in the chat at the bottom right of your screen or during one of our webinars.

Plating (Chrome, Nickel, etc.)

Process Description: Plating involves applying a thin layer of metal, such as chrome or nickel, onto the surface of another metal by electroplating or other methods. This process enhances the metal’s appearance and corrosion resistance, improving its wear resistance and reducing friction.

Advantages/Reason for Use: Plating is widely used for decorative purposes, providing a shiny and attractive finish. It’s also valued for its functional benefits, such as improved corrosion resistance, increased surface hardness, and enhanced durability. Chrome and nickel plating are common in automotive, aerospace, and consumer goods.

Impact on Welding Fumes: Welding chrome or nickel-plated materials can release toxic chromium and nickel fumes. Chromium, especially in its hexavalent form, is a known carcinogen. Nickel fumes can cause metal fume fever, respiratory issues, skin irritation and even cancer.

Thermal Spraying

Process Description: Thermal spraying involves spraying molten or semi-molten materials onto a surface to create a coating. The materials used can include metals, alloys, ceramics, or plastics. It can provide thick coatings at higher deposition rates compared to electroplating. Many processes can be used: plasma spraying, flame spraying, wire arc spraying, detonation spraying, etc.

Advantages/Reason for Use: This process is used to provide wear resistance, corrosion protection, thermal insulation, and to restore dimensions of worn parts. It is beneficial for extending the life of components, improving performance in harsh environments, and repairing damaged parts.

Impact on Welding Fumes: The fumes generated during thermal spraying and subsequent welding depend on the materials used in the coating. Considering the number of materials and processes that can be used, it is impossible to give an exact answer. Metal coatings can produce metal fumes, while ceramic or plastic coatings might release various chemical compounds when exposed to high welding temperatures.

Epoxy Coatings

Process Description: Epoxy coatings are typically two-component systems consisting of an epoxy resin and a hardener. They are applied to metal surfaces to form a durable, chemically resistant protective layer. The curing process involves a chemical reaction between the resin and hardener, creating a solid bond with the metal surface.

Advantages/Reason for Use: These coatings are known for their strong adhesion, high mechanical and thermal resistance, and excellent chemical resistance. They are commonly used in environments where protection against harsh chemicals, abrasion, and corrosion is necessary, such as in industrial settings, pipelines, and automotive applications.

Impact on Welding Fumes: Heat can decompose epoxy coatings during welding, potentially releasing various organic compounds (VOCs). These fumes can irritate the respiratory system, nose, throat, and eyes. Prolonged or high-level exposure can result in asthma or may pose more serious health risks.

Sherardizing (Zinc Thermal Diffusion)

Process Description: Sherardizing is a process in which ferrous parts are coated with zinc dust and heated in a sealed container, resulting in zinc diffusion into the part’s surface, forming a zinc-iron alloy layer. The coating is uniform, even on complex shapes.

Advantages/Reason for Use: This coating technique is primarily used for its corrosion resistance, especially for small components and complex geometries where uniform coating can be challenging.

Impact on Welding Fumes: Similar to galvanizing, sherardizing can release zinc oxide fumes during welding. These fumes, if inhaled, can cause metal fume fever, among other things.

Phosphate Coating

Process Description: Phosphate coating involves the application of a zinc, iron, or manganese phosphate solution to metals such as steel, aluminum, or silver. A mix of phosphoric acid and iron, zinc or manganese salts is applied to the metal. This process can be done through immersion or spraying.

Advantages/Reason for Use: Phosphate coatings are primarily used to enhance paint adhesion and to improve corrosion resistance. They also provide a good base for lubricants, making them ideal for metal parts that require frequent lubrication. This coating is common in automotive and military applications and in the manufacturing of appliances and machinery.

Impact on Welding Fumes: Welding phosphate-coated materials can release various phosphate compounds into the air. While phosphates are generally less hazardous than other compounds, such as zinc or chromium, they can still pose respiratory risks. Inhalation of phosphate particles or fumes can irritate the respiratory tract.

Conclusion

Understanding the complexities of metal coatings and their impact on welding fumes is crucial for ensuring the quality of welding work and the safety of welders. Each coating offers unique benefits like enhanced corrosion resistance and improved aesthetics. However, they also introduce specific challenges regarding the welding fumes they generate.

It is generally recommended to remove any coating on both sides and a few inches away from the surface to be welded. To do so safely, you must follow the directions provided by your supplier. Otherwise, you might create other health problems for workers.

For more comprehensive guidance on managing welding fumes effectively, I invite you to explore our detailed 8-Step Method to Manage Welding Fume. This resource offers practical steps and insights to help you create a safer welding environment, ensuring you’re well-equipped to handle the nuances of welding across various coated metals.