In the world of welding, managing fumes is not just a matter of workplace cleanliness but also of health and safety. Fumes generated during welding processes can pose significant health risks to operators. Fume extraction systems are employed to mitigate these risks, each designed to suit different welding environments and needs.
This article delves into two primary types of fume extraction systems: low-vacuum/high-volume and high-vacuum/low-volume. Each design offers unique benefits and challenges, making it crucial for welding professionals to understand their differences to choose the most appropriate solution for their specific welding applications.
Understanding Low-Vacuum/High-Volume Systems
Low-vacuum/high-volume systems are usually powered by a conventional industrial vacuum blower that generates less than 25″ H2O of negative pressure. Despite the medium to low vacuum pressure, these systems effectively handle large volumes of air, often in the thousands or even tens of thousands of cubic feet per minute (CFM), making them capable of capturing welding fumes over a broad area.
On top of the vacuum blower, critical components of the low-vacuum/high-volume welding fume extraction system include flexible arms, extraction hoods, downdraft tables, and dust collectors for fume filtration.
- Extraction Hoods: These hoods, positioned over the welding area, are designed to capture fumes before they disperse, covering larger areas for extensive welding tasks.
- Downdraft Tables: Essential in stationary grinding and cutting setups, these tables draw particles downward, ensuring a clear workspace and reducing the worker’s fume and dust exposure.
- Flexible Arms: Allow for easy adjustment, capturing fumes while offering flexibility and visibility for the welder. The smaller the diameter of the arms, the more vacuum and the less volume will be necessary to extract welding fumes.
- General Ventilation: Alongside specific components like flexible arms and downdraft tables, general ventilation plays a crucial role in low-vacuum/high-volume systems. It ensures the dilution and removal of residual welding fumes from the broader workspace (usually, a minimum of 4 air changes per hour is required), complementing the targeted extraction provided by other components. Properly designed general ventilation is critical to maintaining a safe and compliant welding environment.
Despite their expansive coverage, these systems usually perform fume extraction at a distance further from the source than high-vacuum/low-volume systems. The effectiveness of these systems heavily relies on the correct positioning of the hood. They are versatile and work for various welding environments, especially TIG or stick welding, although they might be less effective at capturing highly concentrated fumes directly at the welding point.
Exploring High-Vacuum/Low-Volume Systems
High-vacuum/low-volume systems are distinct in their use of a high-vacuum turbine, capable of generating a negative pressure greater than 100″ H2O. This high vacuum pressure and a lower air volume make these systems particularly effective for source extraction close to the welding point (2 to 4 inches).
A high-vacuum/low-volume system is usually designed with a vacuum turbine, fume extraction MIG guns or micro captors, and a dust collector.
- Fume Extraction MIG Guns: These specialized guns are integral to high-vacuum/low-volume systems. They directly capture fumes at the source, reducing the fume’s chance to disperse into the environment. They offer the most reliable fume extraction for MIG welding.
- Micro Captors like Extraction Nozzles: Micro captors play a vital role in high-vacuum/low-volume systems. They are designed to capture fumes as close to the emission source as possible.
High-vacuum/low-volume systems are particularly suited for operations where precise fume extraction is needed at the welding source. Their design allows for efficient capture of fumes from more concentrated sources, such as specific points in the welding process, making them ideal for environments where localized fume generation is a concern. This high pressure is required to allow for the use of longer and narrower hoses.
Any questions? Ask them directly in the chat at the bottom right of your screen or during one of our webinars.
Comparative Analysis: Low-Vacuum/High-Volume vs. High-Vacuum/Low-Volume Systems
When comparing low-vacuum/high-volume and high-vacuum/low-volume systems, several key factors come into play:
Efficiency in Fume Extraction:
- Low-vacuum/high-volume systems efficiently capture fumes over larger areas but may not be as effective at extracting highly concentrated fumes close to the source.
- High-vacuum/low-volume systems excel in capturing fumes directly at the welding source, making them more suitable for operations where concentrated fume extraction is possible (like for MIG welding).
Operational Costs:
- Low-vacuum/high-volume systems may have lower initial costs but could be less efficient in energy usage due to the high volume of air processed.
- High-vacuum/low-volume systems, while potentially costlier upfront due to specialized equipment like high-vacuum turbines, often provide more targeted fume extraction, potentially saving on energy costs in the long term.
Suitability for Different Welding Environments:
- Low-vacuum/high-volume systems are versatile for various processes like Stick and TIG welding.
- High-vacuum/low-volume systems are ideal for MIG welding stations or where precise, localized fume extraction is necessary.
Ease of Use and Maintenance:
- Both systems require regular maintenance, including filter changes and checks on extraction efficiency. However, the specific maintenance needs may vary depending on the system type and the usage intensity.
Overall, the choice between these two systems depends on the specific requirements of the welding environment, including the welding process type, the welding area layout, and the level of fume concentration typically produced.
Best System Depending on the Welding Process
Selecting the right fume extraction system depends heavily on the specific welding process. This section will provide a guide to help determine the most suitable fume extraction system—low-vacuum/high-volume or high-vacuum/low-volume—based on various welding processes.
In the following table, we use the following acronyms:
- HVLV: High-vacuum/low-volume
- LVHV: Low-vacuum/High-volume
Process | MIG gun | Arm | Nozzle | Hood | Table |
Technology | HVLV | LVHV | HVLV | LVHV | LVHV |
MIG / GMAW | Best | Yes | Yes | No | No |
TIG / GTAW | No | Best | Yes | No | No |
Fluxed-Cored / FCAW | Best | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Stick / SMAW | No | Best | Yes | No | No |
Robotic Welding | Yes | Yes* | No | Best | No |
Aluminum Welding | Best** | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Grinding*** | No | No | No | No | Yes |
Plasma Cutting**** | No | No | No | No | Yes |
** When MIG welding aluminum, a fume extraction MIG gun such as AIRGOMIG will be the most efficient (with an aluminum liner). Otherwise, a flexible arm is a good option.
*** On-tool extraction is possible for grinders and would be the most efficient solution in most cases.
**** For a CNC plasma table, it is possible to extract at the source with a Teflon extraction nozzle.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the choice between low-vacuum/high-volume and high-vacuum/low-volume fume extraction systems is a critical decision for ensuring safety and efficiency in welding operations. Each system has unique strengths and is suited to different welding environments and requirements.
By understanding the specific needs of your welding process and the characteristics of these systems, you can make an informed decision that enhances the work environment’s safety and productivity. Remember, the right fume extraction solution contributes to health and regulatory compliance and the overall quality of welding work.
3 Ways to Take a First Step Towards a Fume-Free Environment
1 – Attend Our Webinar
2 – Request our Compact Guide “30 Expert Tips for Eliminating Fume”
You will also receive information about regulations, success stories, tips to choose the right fume extractor.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
3 – Contact Us
We would be pleased to help you protect your welders and comply with current standards. We travel everywhere in Canada and the United States for free demos.
1-800-922-2522
info@henlex.com
Or use our chat system at the bottom right corner get an answer to your questions now.